Ricky Bumgardner Jr | 1.20.2026
Carley Jo Penner Enters Senior Season at UCF Softball with Faith at the Center
As Carley Jo Penner prepares to enter her senior year with UCF Softball, her focus goes far beyond the stat sheet. For Penner, faith isn’t something she turns to only in big moments—it’s the foundation of who she is as an athlete, teammate, and leader within the Knights program.
Recently, Penner sat down with Mays Sports Media’s Charles Mays and Ricky Bumgardner Jr. for a heartfelt conversation about her journey at UCF, the growth she’s experienced over her collegiate career, and the role faith plays in her daily routine. What stood out most was how naturally her belief system is woven into her competitive mindset.
“We play worship music all the time when we are hitting,” Penner shared. That clearly helps keep athletes like CJ grounded, calm, and focused on the bigger picture.
That bigger picture has guided Penner through the highs and lows of college softball. The grind of long seasons, expectations, and pressure-filled moments can challenge even the most talented athletes. For Penner, faith provides peace in the chaos—reminding her that her identity is not defined by batting averages or wins and losses.
Entering her senior season, Penner understands the responsibility that comes with experience. Younger players look to her not only for performance, but for consistency, encouragement, and leadership by example. She embraces that role with humility, believing that leadership starts with how you serve others.
Ad by Four One Sports - Cross Batting Gloves for just $34.99
That mindset aligns perfectly with the culture UCF Softball continues to build under Head Coach Cindy Ball Malone—one rooted in accountability, unity, and purpose. Penner’s presence in the locker room and on the field reflects those values, making her impact felt well beyond the box score.
As the Knights prepare for another competitive season, Penner’s senior year represents more than just a final chapter. It’s a testament to growth—spiritually, mentally, and athletically. Her story serves as a reminder that faith and fierce competition are not opposites, but powerful partners.
